The term mafias typically refers to a wide array of criminal organizations, often characterized by a rigid hierarchical internal organization, engagement in different illegal activities (e.g., drug selling, predatory crimes), and illegal governance over a given territory (Paoli, 2004; Travaglino & Drury, 2020; Von Lampe, 2016). Within the territories where they are embedded, mafias may be able to control criminality by forbidding certain crimes and enforcing such bans through their own code of “justice,” exert power over businesses by demanding a “tax” for operating in areas controlled by mafias, and extort people in exchange for “protection” (Paoli, 2004; Siebert, 2003; Von Lampe, 2016). Such illegal governance is inherently political in nature, as through these practices mafias exercise forms of power and authority typically associated with state institutions (Paoli, 2004). The continued existence of mafias relies not only on fear of retribution, but also on the population’s legitimization of their authority (Travaglino & Abrams, 2019; Travaglino & Drury, 2020).
Given the prevalence of mafias and their societal impact, understanding why local populations confer legitimacy to these organizations is crucial. Prior research suggests that a mafia’s legitimacy is rooted in the endorsement of a masculine honor ideology, which condones the use of violence when individuals feel dishonored or disrespected (Travaglino & Abrams, 2019; Travaglino et al., 2016; Travaglino & Drury, 2020). Although this literature advances our understanding of the cultural factors that influence mafias’ legitimacy, less is known about individual motivations that may guide this process. Based on the quest for significance theory, we propose that the need for significance, a fundamental human need to matter, be respected, and be recognized (Kruglanski et al., 2009, 2019), predicts the endorsement of mafia-aligned values and ideologies, thereby supporting perceived legitimacy.
Honor cultures and masculinity norms have both been highlighted as narratives that define how individuals can attain significance within their cultural contexts (Kruglanski et al., 2022). We posit that ideologies such as the masculine honor code, together with self-enhancement values such as power and wealth, sustain mafia influence and contribute to legitimizing their authority (Hess, 2011; Schneider & Schneider, 2007; Travaglino & Abrams, 2019; Travaglino & Drury, 2020).
Mafias’ Legitimacy
Mafia organizations exert strong influence on social, political, and economic aspects of the territories where they operate (e.g., Felson, 2006; Hess, 2011; Schneider & Schneider, 2003, 2007; Siebert, 1998). This influence is bolstered by omertà, a culturally embedded code of silence in which individuals refrain from interfering with criminal activity to avoid retaliation (Travaglino & Abrams, 2019; Travaglino & Drury, 2020). Omertà goes beyond fear or passivity, encompassing broader, culturally structured ways in which communities regulate coexistence under mafia presence. It often functions as a “solidarity agreement,” in which individuals protect each other and guarantee immunity to those who commit crimes (Schneider & Schneider, 2007; Travaglino & Abrams, 2019; Travaglino & Drury, 2020).
Even though fear of violent retaliation may explain much of mafia influence, local communities are not necessarily exclusively passive victims of mafias. Mafias’ power also depends on collusion, reciprocity, and symbolic and attitudinal legitimacy from local populations (Schneider & Schneider, 2007; Travaglino & Abrams, 2019; Travaglino & Drury, 2020). Schneider and Schneider (2007) identify two processes establishing organic connections between Cosa Nostra and their surroundings: a process of conditioning elite interlocutors, such as politicians and business owners, through webs of mutual reciprocity, and a process of provisioning, taking care of, and assisting ordinary people with solutions to their problems. These processes secure community endorsement and perceived legitimacy without requiring the use of violence, although the threat of retaliation remains.
According to intracultural appropriation theory (Travaglino & Abrams, 2019; Travaglino & Drury, 2020), groups gain legitimacy by portraying themselves as prototypical embodiments of culturally valued norms and ideologies. Mafias, for example, symbolically enact masculine honor ideology, making them appear as legitimate carriers of the social order. Their authority relies not only on power and coercion but also on the embeddedness of a masculine honor ideology within the broader social and cultural context, in which dominance, respect, and retaliation shape social norms (e.g., in southern Italian regions; Peristiany, 1966). Endorsement of a masculine honor ideology is associated with positive attitudes toward mafias and increased contact with their members (Travaglino et al., 2016; Travaglino & Drury, 2019).
While local endorsement of the mafias’ ideological universe is crucial to their legitimacy (e.g., Travaglino & Abrams, 2019; Travaglino & Drury, 2020), previous research has largely neglected the individual motivations that lead people to legitimate criminal groups through the endorsement of their values. One motivation that may play a meaningful role in this process is that of the quest for significance (Kruglanski et al., 2022). Although mafia influence is embedded in cultural, relational, and reciprocal networks, these broader structures operate by activating and shaping individual motivations.
The Quest for Significance
Significance-quest theory posits that the quest for significance is a fundamental human motivation to matter, to be valued by others, and to merit respect and dignity, which underlies human social behavior (Kruglanski et al., 2009, 2013, 2019, 2022; Kruglanski, Gelfand, et al., 2014). This need may be activated by situational conditions of deprivation, such as being ignored, disrespected, or humiliated, or incentivization, such as the perceived attainability of valued ends that provide significance (e.g., Kruglanski, Chernikova, et al., 2014; Webber et al., 2018). When activated, individuals become motivated to enact extreme behaviors (e.g., Chirico et al., 2021; Dugas et al., 2016; Kruglanski et al., 2017; Pica, 2026), endorse values, and join groups capable of conferring significance (Kruglanski, Gelfand, et al., 2014; Kruglanski et al., 2009, 2022).
This dynamic is captured by the “3N model” of need, narrative, and network (Kruglanski et al., 2019). According to this model, the need for significance does not influence behavior directly; rather, it is expressed through culturally available narratives that define how recognition and worth can be achieved and are reinforced within relevant social networks. Applied to mafias, when individuals are embedded in social contexts where mafia-related values are shared and reinforced, these narratives provide culturally recognized pathways to significance, which may lead individuals to perceive mafias as legitimate.
We therefore propose that the endorsement of values linked to mafias’ objectives (i.e., self-enhancement values: influence, wealth, authority, and power) and of a masculine honor ideology may support mafias’ legitimacy (see Travaglino & Abrams, 2019; Travaglino et al., 2016; Travaglino & Drury, 2020), because they offer culturally salient routes to achieving significance. From this perspective, lending legitimacy to mafias is not an end in itself, but a way to satisfy the basic need to matter by aligning with socially valued ideals.
The Present Research
Based on these premises, we hypothesized that the quest for significance predicts perceived legitimacy of mafias by means of two parallel mediational processes: (1) the endorsement of self-enhancement values (i.e., influence, wealth, authority, power), and (2) the endorsement of a masculine honor ideology. Study 1 assessed attitudinal tolerance toward mafia-related collusion as an indirect indicator of legitimacy, while Study 2 measured perceived legitimacy directly. Both studies focused on internalized perceptions and endorsements rather than compliance driven by fear.
To test these hypotheses, we conducted a secondary data analysis on cross-sectional data collected for the research project “The Motivational Dynamics Underlying Mafia and Antimafia.” Whereas Pica et al. (2025) examined predictors of anti-mafia action, the present article focuses on the motivational antecedents of perceived mafia legitimacy. The data were collected through two online questionnaires distributed using a snowball sampling method using Google Forms from December 2019 to May 2021. No incentive was offered for participating. At the beginning of the surveys, participants gave their informed consent after being informed about the topic of the research as well as the procedure in accordance with the ethical principles and rules of conduct of the American Psychological Association (APA, 2017).
Study 1
The aim of Study 1 was to test the first mediational hypothesis, that the relationship between the quest for significance and attitudinal tolerance toward mafia-related collusion is mediated by the endorsement of self-enhancement values, given that these values align with the objectives and culture of such criminal organizations (e.g., Felson, 2006; Hess, 2011). We tested this hypothesis by excluding the potential mediating effects of other values assessed in the survey.
Materials and Method
Participants and Procedures
Six hundred and eighty-four Italian citizens (274 women; Mage = 41.22 years, SDage = 11.93) participated in the study. Participants were recruited using snowball sampling via email and social media. Eligibility required being at least 18 years old and residing in Italy. Participation was voluntary, anonymous, and uncompensated. Data were collected online between May and September 2020. Most participants had a high school degree (75.7%), Bachelor’s degree (9.5%), or Master’s degree (9.5%); the rest had a PhD or other professional degree (2.5%), or a middle school education (2.8%). All measures were presented in Italian. An a priori power analysis using 5,000 Monte Carlo simulations indicated a minimum required sample of 264 participants.
Measures
Quest for significance. Quest for significance was assessed by asking participants to what extent they agreed with three statements taken from Molinario and colleagues (2021; unpublished): “I wish I could be more respected”; “I wish I meant more to other people”; and “I wish other people thought I were significant.” Responses were recorded on a seven-point Likert scale ranging from 1 (totally disagree) to 7 (totally agree). The three items were averaged to create a composite quest for significance score (α = .86).
Values. Values were assessed using a short version of Schwartz’s value scale (1992) developed by Stern and colleagues (1998). This scale consists of 15 values that belong to five major clusters: biospheric, altruistic, self-enhancement, openness to change, and conservation values. We added one item to the altruistic values (honesty), and one item to the self-enhancement values (power). Respondents indicated to what extent these values were important “as a guiding principle in their lives” on a seven-point scale. Internal consistency analyses supported the reliability of the dimensions (altruistic values, α = .72; biospheric values, α = .85; self-enhancement values, α = .71; openness to change values, α = .71; and conservation values, α = .50).
Attitudinal tolerance toward mafia-related collusion. Attitudes toward individuals who engage in collusion with mafias were assessed with three ad-hoc items focused on accepting money, loans, or “help” from criminal organizations in times of crisis. Responses were recorded on a seven-point Likert scale. The three items were averaged to compute a composite score, with higher scores indicating greater tolerance (α = .90).
Results
Descriptive statistics and correlations between the key variables of the study are reported in Table 1. Results showed that the quest for significance was positively and significantly correlated with self-enhancement values (r = .32, p < .001), openness to change values (r = .12, p < .01), and attitudinal tolerance toward mafia-related collusion (r = .18, p < .001). Attitudinal tolerance toward mafia-related collusion was negatively and significantly correlated with conservation, biospheric, and altruistic values.
Table 1
Descriptive Statistics, Internal Consistency Estimates, and Correlations Among Study Variables
| Variable | M | SD | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Attitudinal tolerance toward mafia-related collusion | 2.49 | 1.55 | (.90) | ||||||
| 2. Quest for significance | 3.86 | 1.67 | .18*** | (.86) | |||||
| 3. Self-enhancement values | 2.75 | 1.11 | .24*** | .32*** | (.71) | ||||
| 4. Conservation values | 5.28 | 0.65 | -.10** | .05 | .12** | (.50) | |||
| 5. Biospheric values | 5.32 | 0.82 | -.12** | .04 | -.05 | .43*** | (.85) | ||
| 6. Openness to change values | 4.86 | 0.89 | -.02 | .12** | .17*** | .29*** | .39*** | (.71) | |
| 7. Altruistic values | 5.54 | 0.58 | -.17*** | .03 | -.07 | .48*** | .58*** | .38*** | (.72) |
Note. Values on the diagonal (in parentheses) are Cronbach's α coefficients.
*p < .05. **p < .01. ***p < .001.
Multiple Mediation Model
The multiple mediation model analysis was tested according to Hayes’s (2018) recommendations. Specifically, Model 4 in the PROCESS macro was tested with 5,000 bootstrap samples. The direct and indirect effects between the quest for significance and attitudinal tolerance toward mafia-related collusion were examined while modeling self-enhancement values as the hypothesized mediator. Biospheric, conservation, openness to change, and altruistic values were also entered as potential mediators.
Quest for significance positively and significantly predicted endorsement of self-enhancement values, B = .21, SE = .02, 95% CI [.164, .259], p < .001, which, in turn, positively and significantly predicted attitudinal tolerance toward mafia-related collusion, B = .28, SE = .06, 95% CI [.172, .391], p < .001. The indirect effect of quest for significance on attitudinal tolerance toward mafia-related collusion via self-enhancement values was significant and positive (indirect effect = .060, BootSE = .014, 95% CI [.034, .090]). No other indirect effect was significant. In summary, the proposed mediation model was supported.1 (See Figure 1).
Figure 1
Hypothesized Multiple Mediation Model
Note. Unstandardized coefficients are reported. Solid lines indicate significant paths. Dashed lines indicate non-significant paths.
Study 2
The results of Study 1 provided initial support for the prediction that the quest for significance positively predicts attitudinal indicators of perceived legitimacy toward mafia-related practices through the endorsement of self-enhancement values. Study 2 was designed to extend and strengthen these findings by replicating the observed mediational effect of self-enhancement values, testing masculine honor ideology as a second mediational pathway, and incorporating a more direct measure of mafia legitimacy.
Materials and Method
Participants and Procedures
Two hundred and ninety-nine Italian citizens (216 women; Mage = 26.71 years, SDage = 12.76) participated in this study. Participants were recruited using the same snowball sampling procedure described in Study 1. The sample included mostly university students but also individuals from outside the university. Eligibility, voluntary participation, and anonymity were the same as in Study 1. Data were collected online between April and May 2021. Most participants had a high school degree (77.5%), Bachelor’s degree (11.4%), or Master’s degree (5%); the rest had a PhD or other professional degree (0.7%), or a middle school education (5.4%). All measures were presented in Italian. A sample of 250 participants was suggested by 5,000 Monte Carlo simulations, and the final sample exceeded this minimum.
Measures
Quest for significance. Quest for significance was assessed using the same items as in Study 1. Items were averaged to create a composite score (α = .75).
Values. Values were assessed using the same scale used in Study 1. Items corresponding to each value dimension were averaged to create composite scores (altruistic values, α = .77; biospheric values, α = .88; self-enhancement values, α = .77; openness to change values, α = .63; and conservation values, α = .50).
Masculine honor ideology. Masculine honor ideology was assessed by adapting eight items taken from Travaglino and colleagues (2014), who previously modified the original Honor Ideology for Manhood scale (Barnes et al., 2012). Responses were recorded on a seven-point Likert scale. The items were averaged to compute a single composite score, with higher scores indicating stronger endorsement of masculine honor ideology (α = .89).
Attitudes regarding the legitimacy of mafias. Attitudes regarding the legitimacy of mafias were assessed by two items taken from Travaglino and colleagues (2016): “Some aspects of mafias activity are legitimate” and “Some actions of mafias may have positive direct or indirect consequences for the area where you live.” Responses were recorded on a seven-point Likert scale. The two items were averaged to compute a single composite score; the two items were highly correlated (Spearman-Brown’s r = .51, p < .001).
Results
Descriptive statistics and correlations between the key variables are reported in Table 2. Results showed that the quest for significance was positively and significantly correlated with the endorsement of a masculine honor ideology and self-enhancement values (r = .21, p < .001; r = .26, p < .001, respectively). Attitudes regarding the legitimacy of mafias were negatively and significantly correlated with conservation, biospheric, openness to change, and altruistic values.
Table 2
Descriptive Statistics, Internal Consistency Estimates, and Correlations Among Study Variables
| Variable | M | SD | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Attitudes regarding the legitimacy of mafias | 1.87 | 1.23 | (.51) | |||||||
| 2. Quest for significance | 4.80 | 1.34 | .07 | (.75) | ||||||
| 3. Masculine honor ideology | 3.07 | 1.41 | .34*** | .21*** | (.89) | |||||
| 4. Self-enhancement values | 3.08 | 1.24 | .27*** | .26*** | .43*** | (.77) | ||||
| 5. Conservation values | 5.32 | 0.71 | -.27*** | .11 | .14* | .10 | (.50) | |||
| 6. Biospheric values | 5.19 | 1.02 | -.38*** | .06 | -.14* | -.11* | .49*** | (.88) | ||
| 7. Openness to change values | 5.00 | 0.90 | -.18*** | .00 | .03 | .20** | .35*** | .40*** | (.63) | |
| 8. Altruistic values | 5.46 | 0.73 | -.40*** | .10 | -.21*** | -.16** | .57*** | .68*** | .34*** | (.77) |
Note. Values on the diagonal (in parentheses) indicate internal consistency estimates. The coefficient for attitudes regarding the legitimacy of mafias is the Spearman–Brown coefficient; all other coefficients are Cronbach's α.
*p < .05. **p < .01. ***p < .001.
Multiple Parallel Mediation Model
The multiple parallel mediation model analysis was tested according to Hayes’s (2018) recommendations. Specifically, Model 4 in the PROCESS macro was tested with 5,000 bootstrap samples. The direct and indirect effects between the quest for significance and attitudes regarding the legitimacy of mafias were examined while modeling masculine honor ideology and self-enhancement values as mediators. Biospheric, conservation, openness to change, and altruistic values were also entered as potential mediators.
Quest for significance positively and significantly predicted endorsement of a masculine honor ideology, B = .22, SE = .06, 95% CI [.098, .333], p < .001, which, in turn, positively and significantly predicted attitudes regarding the legitimacy of mafias, B = .22, SE = .05, 95% CI [.123, .322], p < .001. Furthermore, the quest for significance positively and significantly predicted endorsement of self-enhancement values, B = .24, SE = .05, 95% CI [.134, .338], p < .001, which, in turn, positively and significantly predicted attitudes regarding the legitimacy of mafias, B = .15, SE = .06, 95% CI [.037, .266], p < .01. The indirect effects via masculine honor ideology and self-enhancement values were significant and positive (indirect effect = .048, BootSE = .018, 95% CI [.017, .086]; indirect effect = .036, BootSE = .020, 95% CI [.0003, .079], respectively). No other indirect effect was significant.2 (See Figure 2).
Figure 2
Hypothesized Multiple Parallel Mediation Model
Note. Unstandardized coefficients are reported. Solid lines indicate significant paths. Dashed lines indicate non-significant paths.
General Discussion
This article aimed to analyze the motivational role of the quest for significance in shaping individual perceptions of the legitimacy of mafia organizations. The results of two cross-sectional studies provided empirical evidence that the quest for significance has indirect effects on perceived legitimacy of mafias through the endorsement of values and ideologies aligned with the objectives and cultural narrative of these organizations (e.g., Felson, 2006; Hess, 2011). Study 1 found that the quest for significance positively predicts attitudinal tolerance toward mafia-related collusion through the endorsement of self-enhancement values, while excluding the potential mediating effects of other values. Study 2 replicated the findings of Study 1 and added an analysis of the mediational role of masculine honor ideology, previously found to be linked to perceived legitimacy of mafias (Travaglino et al., 2016).
From a theoretical standpoint, these results are consistent with the quest for significance theory (Kruglanski, Gelfand, et al., 2014; Kruglanski et al., 2022), which holds that the quest for significance can lead people to endorse culturally available ideologies and values that promise recognition and personal worth. Although the present studies did not assess endorsement of violent acts directly, they examined perceived legitimacy of mafia organizations whose authority and power are strictly intertwined with the use of violence (Paoli, 2004; Travaglino & Drury, 2020; Von Lampe, 2016).
This interpretation is consistent with the 3N model (Kruglanski et al., 2019), according to which personal needs for significance are expressed through culturally available narratives and reinforced within social networks that validate specific routes to status and recognition. The results also align with intracultural appropriation theory (Travaglino & Abrams, 2019; Travaglino & Drury, 2020), as mafias gain influence by symbolically embodying culturally valued ideals, thereby appearing as prototypical carriers of the social order.
By connecting the quest for significance to perceived legitimacy of mafias, this research extends prior studies linking the same motivational dynamics to support for terrorism (Kruglanski, Gelfand, et al., 2014; Kruglanski et al., 2009, 2019, 2022). It suggests that different forms of support for extreme or criminal organizations, whether terrorist groups or mafias, share a common motivational substrate rooted in the pursuit of personal significance.
In addition to contributing to the literature on significance-quest theory, the present research contributes to the literature on mafias by addressing a motivational aspect that has been largely neglected in research on factors underlying mafias’ support, and by broadening our understanding of the cultural values that sustain mafia influence. The pursuit of wealth, power, and influence complements adherence to a masculine honor ideology in explaining support for mafia organizations.
Limitations and Directions for Future Research
This research is not without limitations. First, the studies are correlational, and therefore causal inferences cannot be drawn. Future studies should replicate the present results longitudinally or use experiments in which the quest for significance is manipulated through conditions of deprivation or incentivization. Second, the present research focused on attitudinal perceptions rather than concrete behavioral outcomes. Future research may test whether perceived legitimacy of mafias predicts intentions to join such groups, particularly among youth.
Third, the value-based pathway may not be the only mechanism linking the quest for significance to individual attitudes toward legitimacy of mafia organizations. Significance may also be achieved through a process of vicarious identification with powerful mafia members. Future studies may test whether the link between the quest for significance and attitudes toward legitimacy of mafias is mediated by participants’ admiration of and identification with these groups and their members. Finally, our online samples did not assess participants’ exposure to mafia-dominated environments, limiting the generalizability of the findings. Differences in local embeddedness and exposure to mafia influence could moderate the observed relationships.
In sum, the findings should be interpreted cautiously, as the correlational design, attitudinal measures, and online sampling limit causal inference and generalizability.
Conclusion
The present research provides evidence suggesting that the quest for significance is associated with perceived legitimacy of mafia organizations through the endorsement of self-enhancement values and a masculine honor ideology. By integrating motivational theory with culturally grounded explanations of mafia influence, this work highlights why individuals internalize and legitimize mafia-aligned cultural values and ideologies. Given the harmful consequences of mafia control and influence, understanding such processes is critical to reducing mafia influence and its detrimental effects.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the